Blog

Is a False Diagnosis Considered Failure to Diagnose?

medical diagnosis

A false diagnosis is a type of diagnostic failure that can cause serious consequences. Watch the video below as Bill Hinnant explains why a failure to diagnose might occur and why it can be potentially deadly.

A false diagnosis can happen when a doctor or radiologist does one of the following things:

  • Misreads an imaging study
  • Misreads a lab report
  • Fails to order another test to confirm a diagnosis
  • Fails to order a differential test to determine whether a condition is of one type or another

A patient who receives a false diagnosis for a benign condition might suffer serious harm if he or she has a more serious condition. Serious harm can also result when a patient is falsely diagnosed with a serious condition and receives unnecessary treatment.

What Doctors Must Do to Avoid 

Doctors must make sure that they obtain all possible information about a medical condition to make an appropriate diagnosis and effectively treat the patient. Imaging studies, lab tests, and electrophysiological studies are not infallible. While they are helpful tools, they have limits. Some are unclear, requiring doctors to follow up with additional tests. When an abnormality is identified, a doctor might need to order additional tests to correctly diagnose the condition.

Accuracy is critical. When a doctor fails to properly diagnose a serious condition, the patient’s condition might significantly worsen. A misdiagnosed patient might suffer permanent disabilities or death because of not receiving the correct treatment.

Consult An Experienced Medical Malpractice Attorney

If you believe that you were falsely diagnosed and suffered serious harm because of your doctor’s medical negligence, you should consult a physician -attorney at LawMD. As both physicians and attorneys, we have decades of experience handling failure to diagnose and other medical negligence cases. Contact us today for a free consultation by calling (833) MY-LAWMD.

Learn More:

Delayed Diagnosis

Is a Delay in Diagnosis Considered Failure to Diagnose?

What Is Failure to Diagnose?

Video Transcript

Timestamps
0:46 Proper Diagnosis & Treatment
1:05 X-Rays & Lab Tests
2:29 Accuracy is Important

It would be. And I think again, that’s why I mentioned in my first example, and again it’s a true story about the orthopedic surgeon.

0:46 Proper Diagnosis & Treatment

You need to not only know exactly what’s wrong in the case of a medical illness of any kind. You need to delineate it and know everything about it that is possibly obtainable in order to 

  1. Make the proper diagnosis, and then
  2. Effectively treat it

1:05 X-Rays & Lab Tests

As our listeners probably realize, x-rays and lab tests, electrophysiological studies, whatever the case may be, these studies have limits. Some are better than others. Certain x-rays are like looking through a dirty window and others are pristine. You may get a grainy poor image or you may get almost a perfect image.

But when you have an abnormality, you need to go potentially from one imaging technique to a different one to really know what the diagnosis is. You may need to follow up an abnormal lab test with a different lab test. You may need to take some study that’s been done, and follow it up with another study to be sure you know exactly what you’re treating. Because in many cases, entities that could be totally benign, and be confused with more serious entities. And of course, that’s ok when you have a benign entity.

But on the other hand, when an illness is potentially serious, is misidentified as a benign entity, you could have a real problem that could lead to significant morbidity, disability, or mortality on behalf of that patient. And again, none of us, I think, wants to wish any untoward consequence on one of our fellow human beings.

2:29 Accuracy is Important

So yes, it’s important to know exactly what you’re dealing with. These are cases where you can’t be generally right. You have to be on the money, every time, and know exactly what you’re dealing with.

So the shortfalls in those cases may be the failure to get a particular lab test, the failure to get a particular x-ray.

Years ago, I had a case involving differential diagnosis of two entities that are somewhat alike. One was multiple sclerosis, which many of you have heard of. And the other is a disease which many of you have not heard of called Devic’s disease, or neuromyelitis optica.

Those two entities on the surface can look very much alike. But there is one laboratory test that distinguishes the two. And the reason that’s important is that the treatment for the two is much different. And you want to be sure that you know exactly what you’re dealing with upfront because a subtle difference may make the difference in a correct diagnosis versus an incorrect diagnosis. And likewise in the damages involved. That is whether the patient actually gets better or whether they continue to suffer adverse consequences, pain, suffering, whatever the case may be.

Recommended Posts

Who Can Be Held Liable for Injuries From a Defective Medical Device?

If you or a loved have been injured by a defective medical device, you could already be facing a frustrating game of "pass the buck" as various involved entities try to deny responsibility or shift it to someone else. Talk to an Atlanta, GA medical malpractice attorney as soon as possible. An experienced lawyer will be able to cut through the jargon and games and help you hold the right parties responsible. Who Can Be Held Liable for Injuries From a Defective Medical Device? There are five entities that typically may be responsible in these cases: Manufacturer of the device Manufacturer of a device's component Distributor, packager, or seller Hospital or similar facitlity Treating physician or other healthcare worker The Device Manufacturer The manufacturer is liable if someone is injured because the device, when the manufacturer sold it, was not serviceable and reasonably suited for the use intended. If that's what caused the injury, then you as the injured person don't have to prove carelessness on the part of the manufacturer. The fact that they sold something that wasn't fit to purpose is enough. This covers all issues from design defects to manufacturing defects to inadequate warnings or instructions, so long as the device was defective when it left the manufacturer. The manufacturer may also be sued for negligence in certain cases. A Component Manufacturer Liability here will depend on whether the component was defective when the manufacturer sold it or whether it was the later assembly process altered the part in such a way as to render it defective (in which case the manufacturer of the whole device is to blame). Distributors, Packagers, and Sellers Ordinarily, someone who leases, sells, distributes, packages, labels, markets, or assembles a device, so long as they do so according to the manufacturer's plan, design, or specifications, wouldn't be held liable. However, a product seller may still be sued under ordinary negligence rules if they knew or should have known of the defect and continued to sell it, or if they altered the device on their own. Hospital or Healthcare Facility A hospital that furnishes a device isn't treated as a seller, and Georgia courts have dismissed warranty and product claims against hospitals on that ground. However, the hospital may still be responsible under medical-malpractice principles if its own employees or agents were negligent in the way they chose what devices to purchase or the way they stored or used them. Treating Healthcare Professional Finally, the doctor or other professional who prescribed and implanted the device could potentially be liable if the implantation itself wasn't done according to the standard of care, such as if the doctor didn't tell you about all potential concerns and thus didn't get proper informed consent. Talk to an Atlanta, GA Medical Malpractice Attorney If you've been injured by a medical device, contact LawMD Chartered in Atlanta, GA or Washington, DC online to set up a free case evaluation. Our team of lawyers are also doctors. We understand standards of care and what to look for to show whose negligence is the cause of your injury.

What Counts as Postoperative Negligence After Surgery?

Complications aren't uncommon after surgeries, but when they come from failures in monitoring or response, a medical malpractice lawyer in Washington, DC can help you determine if postoperative negligence played a role and whether you have a claim. Postoperative Negligence Cases in Washington, DC Postoperative care starts the moment the procedure ends and continues through the recovery room, the hospital stay, and your follow-up visits at home. Providers must protect your airway, manage fluids and blood pressure, control pain, prevent blood clots, check mental status, monitor urine output, and care for the surgical wound. They must also watch for fever, encourage early movement, and confirm you meet basic discharge criteria before sending you home. If they fail in these steps and you suffer harm as a result, you may have a case. Monitoring Issues After surgery your vital signs, oxygen levels, and overall condition need close tracking, especially in the first hours and days. Providers should check for increasing pain, any swelling or drainage, fever, shortness of breath, or changes in your mental status. If they ignore repeated complaints of increasing pain or fail to investigate other abnormal readings, early warning signs of internal bleeding, infection, or organ distress can go unnoticed and the result can be serious. Infection Infection can happen; the real issue is catching it early and treating it. Providers must leave sterile dressings in place for the first day or two unless infection signs appear and then inspect the site regularly. Signs of infection include increasing pain, redness, swelling, warmth, or pus-like drainage. If the staff skip these checks, delay the use of antibiotics, or fail to drain an abscess properly, the infection can spread and cause sepsis. Blood Clots Surgery and the limited movement afterward always raise the chance of developing deep vein thrombosis or a pulmonary embolism. Standard care in these situations includes prophylaxis such as medication or compression devices, plus early ambulation. If your providers didn't do these things, or if they missed leg swelling, calf pain, or sudden breathing difficulty, a clot could form and travel to the lungs. This is one of the most serious post-operative complications and must be guarded against very carefully. Left Items Sponges, instruments, guide wires, or fragments left inside the body during surgery are "never events": in other words, they must never happen, and there's never any excuse for them. If something was left inside you during a surgery, this is always cause to bring a claim. Pain Control Physicians and healthcare providers have a duty to control patient pain, and uncontrolled pain can put a great deal of strain on the cardiovascular system and interfere with the healing process. Pain control requires a careful balance; excessive opioids can slow breathing or cause confusion, but under-treatment with acetaminophen or inferior painkillers like sodium channel blockers or even antidepressants leaves you in severe discomfort and can be cause to bring an action. Talk With an Experienced Medical Malpractice Lawyer Contact LawMD Chartered in Washington, DC today to talk with attorneys who are also doctors. We can examine the medical records with clinical training and a legal eye and help you discover what your rights are and then pursue them.

How Long Do You Have to File a Medical Malpractice Claim in Washington, DC?

If you or someone you love suffered harm due to a healthcare provider's negligence, one of the first and most critical questions you need answered is: how long do you have to file a medical malpractice claim? The answer depends on several legal factors, including where the incident occurred, when you discovered the injury, and who was involved. In Washington, DC, missing the filing deadline can permanently bar you from recovering compensation — no matter how strong your case may be. At LawMD Chartered, our attorneys bring a rare combination of medical and legal knowledge to every case we handle. With board-certified MDs and seasoned attorneys working together under one roof, we evaluate medical malpractice claims with a level of clinical and legal precision that sets our firm apart. If you believe you have a claim, do not wait. Contact us today at 833-695-2963 or visit our contact page to request a free case evaluation. Understanding the Medical Malpractice Statute of Limitations in Washington, DC The statute of limitations is the legal deadline, or time limit, by which you must file your lawsuit. In Washington, DC, the general statute of limitations for medical malpractice claims is three years from the date the injury occurred — or from the date you discovered, or reasonably should have discovered, the injury. This is known as the discovery rule, and it plays a significant role in many malpractice cases where the harm was not immediately apparent. For example, if a surgeon left a foreign object, such as a surgical instrument, inside your body during a procedure at MedStar Georgetown University Hospital or George Washington University Hospital, and you did not discover the problem until months later, the three-year clock may begin running from the date of discovery rather than the date of surgery. When a patient discovers a hidden injury later, the discovery rule may delay when the filing period begins. However, the law also places an absolute cap on how far back a claim can reach. In DC, there is a statute of repose that limits claims to no more than five years from the date of the negligent act, regardless of when the injury was discovered. This outer limit applies even if you had no way of knowing about the harm sooner. Understanding how these two deadlines interact is critical. Missing either one means losing your right to pursue compensation entirely. The Discovery Rule: When Does the Clock Start? The discovery rule exists because medical negligence is not always immediately obvious, but once enough facts are known, the clock starts ticking. A misdiagnosis, a delayed diagnosis, or an improperly prescribed medication may cause harm that takes time to manifest. In Washington, DC courts — including the DC Superior Court, where most civil malpractice actions are filed — judges apply the discovery rule to determine when the limitations period began. The clock starts when: You knew about the injury, or You reasonably should have known — based on what a reasonable person would have understood under similar circumstances — that you were injured and that a healthcare provider may have caused the harm This does not mean you must know with certainty that alleged malpractice occurred. It means that once you had enough information to put you on notice that something may have gone wrong medically, the clock begins. At that point, it is your responsibility to investigate and take legal action within the three-year window. LawMD Chartered attorneys work closely with our in-house medical professionals to pinpoint exactly when a client's discovery clock began — a determination that can make or break a case by clarifying when medical malpractice occurred and when it was or should have been discovered. Special Rules That May Affect Your Filing Deadline Washington, DC has several important exceptions and modifications to the standard three-year rule. Knowing these exceptions can mean the difference between having a viable claim and losing your right to sue. Claims Involving Minors When the injured party is a child, the statute of limitations does not begin running until the child turns 18 years old. This means a minor who suffered a birth injury, a surgical error, or a misdiagnosis has until their 21st birthday to file a medical malpractice claim in DC. However, a parent or guardian may still file on the child's behalf before that time. Birth injury cases are among the most emotionally and legally complex cases our team handles. If your child was harmed during delivery at a Washington, DC hospital — whether at Children's National Hospital, Howard University Hospital, or another facility — we encourage you to speak with an attorney as soon as possible to understand your options. Claims Against Government-Employed Healthcare Providers If the negligent provider works for a federal or DC government agency — such as a VA hospital, a federally qualified health center, or a DC Department of Health facility — different rules apply. Claims against federal employees fall under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA), which requires you to: File an administrative claim with the relevant federal agency within two years of the date of injury Wait for the agency to respond (up to six months) File a lawsuit in federal court only after the agency denies the claim or fails to respond within six months This process is entirely different from filing a standard civil lawsuit in DC Superior Court. Missing the two-year administrative deadline under the FTCA is fatal to your claim — and there are very few exceptions. LawMD Chartered has experience navigating both the DC Superior Court system and the federal claims process, ensuring clients do not lose their rights due to procedural missteps. Mental Incapacity If the injured person is legally incapacitated at the time of the malpractice, the statute of limitations may be tolled — meaning paused — until the incapacity ends. This exception is narrowly interpreted by DC courts and must be clearly documented. What Happens If You Miss the Filing Deadline? If you file your medical malpractice lawsuit after the statute of limitations has expired, the defendant's attorney will almost certainly file a motion to dismiss. DC courts take these deadlines seriously. In the vast majority of cases, a late filing means your case will be dismissed — and you will be permanently barred from recovering compensation for your injuries, regardless of how severe they are or how clearly negligent the provider was. This is why acting quickly is so important. The moment you suspect that a healthcare provider's negligence contributed to your injury, you should consult with an attorney. Early action allows your legal team to: Gather and preserve critical medical records before they are altered or destroyed Identify and retain qualified medical witnesses Conduct a thorough investigation of the standard of care File the necessary notices and certifications required under DC law DC's Certificate of Merit Requirement In addition to the statute of limitations, Washington, DC law requires plaintiffs in medical malpractice cases to file a Certificate of Merit at the time the lawsuit is initiated. This certificate must be signed by a qualified healthcare professional who has reviewed the case and believes — based on reasonable medical probability — that the defendant deviated from the applicable standard of care. This requirement is designed to screen out frivolous claims, but it also adds an additional layer of preparation that your legal team must complete before filing. At LawMD Chartered, our in-house medical doctors are uniquely positioned to assist in preparing this certificate quickly and accurately — a process that can take other firms weeks or months to coordinate externally. Why the Standard of Care Matters in DC Malpractice Cases To succeed in a medical malpractice claim in Washington, DC, you must prove that the healthcare provider or medical professional deviated from the accepted standard of care — meaning they failed to act as a reasonably competent provider in the same field would have acted under similar circumstances. This standard applies to: Physicians and surgeons Nurses and nurse practitioners Anesthesiologists Radiologists Emergency room providers Hospitals and healthcare facilities Washington, DC is home to some of the nation's most prestigious medical institutions, including the George Washington University Hospital, MedStar Georgetown University Hospital, Children's National Hospital, and the Walter Reed National Military Medical Center. Even at these highly regarded facilities, errors happen — and proving a deviation often requires a thorough understanding of the treatment at issue and the accepted standard of care, so when they do, patients have the right to hold negligent providers accountable. Common Types of Medical Malpractice Claims Filed in Washington, DC Many medical malpractice claims begin with a medical error. Some of the most common types of cases filed in DC include: Misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis of cancer, heart attacks, strokes, or infections Surgical errors, including wrong-site surgery, anesthesia mistakes, or failure to control bleeding Birth injuries, such as cerebral palsy, Erb's palsy, or hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) Medication errors, including incorrect dosing or prescribing contraindicated drugs Failure to treat, where a provider diagnoses a condition but fails to offer appropriate treatment Emergency room errors, including failure to recognize time-sensitive conditions like sepsis or pulmonary embolism Defective medical devices implanted or used during treatment Each of these claim types has its own evidentiary requirements, and the timeline for discovery may vary because some injuries and other complications are not discovered right away. Our attorneys assess each case individually to determine the precise filing deadline and the best legal strategy. How LawMD Chartered Approaches Medical Malpractice Cases in Washington, DC LawMD Chartered is not a typical personal injury firm. Our practice is built around a foundational belief: that understanding the medicine behind negligent medical care is just as important as understanding the law. As an experienced medical malpractice attorney team working alongside board-certified medical doctors, we review records, evaluate standards of care, and build compelling, medically sound cases. This integrated approach benefits our Washington, DC clients in several meaningful ways: Faster case evaluation: Our MDs can review medical records and assess the viability of a claim in a timely manner, without waiting for outside consultants Stronger case preparation: Medical and legal analysis happen simultaneously, and our lawyers understand both the legal and medical issues involved, reducing delays and improving the quality of evidence presented Credible testimony and support: Our in-house physicians can assist in preparing medical narratives and identifying the right independent medical witnesses Clear communication: We translate complex medical information into language that judges, juries, and the insurance company can understand Our office serves clients throughout the Washington, DC metropolitan area, including residents of Capitol Hill, Columbia Heights, Anacostia, Georgetown, Dupont Circle, Shaw, and beyond. We also serve clients in the surrounding Maryland and Virginia suburbs who received negligent care at DC-area hospitals and medical facilities. What Compensation Can You Recover in a DC Medical Malpractice Case? Victims of medical negligence in Washington, DC may be entitled to recover a range of damages and seek compensation for losses such as: Medical expenses — past and future costs of treatment, rehabilitation, and ongoing care Lost wages — income lost due to the injury, including diminished future earning capacity Pain and suffering — physical pain and emotional distress caused by the negligent act Loss of consortium — the impact on your relationships with a spouse or family members Wrongful death damages — if medical malpractice results in a patient's death, surviving family members may bring a wrongful death claim Washington, DC does not currently cap economic damages in medical malpractice cases, which means there is no statutory limit on the amount of compensation you can recover for medical bills, lost income, and other ongoing losses tied to medical injuries. Non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering, are also uncapped — a significant distinction from many other states. Related Practice Areas at LawMD Chartered Medical malpractice cases often intersect with other areas of personal injury law, and acting on a personal injury claim promptly can be important to protect your rights. If your situation involves any of the following, our team can help: Birth Injury Surgical Errors Brain Injury Spinal Cord Injury Wrongful Death Failure to Treat & Diagnose Emergency Room Errors Permanent Disability Defective Medical Devices Frequently Asked Questions: Filing a Medical Malpractice Claim in Washington, DC How long do you have to file a medical malpractice claim in Washington, DC? In Washington, DC, you generally have three years from the date of injury — or from the date you discovered or reasonably should have discovered the injury — to file a medical malpractice lawsuit. An absolute statute of repose limits claims to five years from the date of the negligent act. Other states use different deadlines, including Maryland’s five-year filing period recognized in maryland courts, Texas’s two-year statute of limitations, and Ohio’s four-year statute of repose with a discovery rule exception, while pennsylvania law and pennsylvania's statute also show how discovery-based timing rules can affect when a claim must be filed. What is the discovery rule in DC medical malpractice cases? The discovery rule means the three-year statute of limitations begins when you knew, or when a reasonable person would have known, of the injury and its likely cause, including when a patient discovers harm from prior treatment later on. It does not require you to have confirmed malpractice occurred. Can a child file a medical malpractice claim after turning 18 in DC? Yes. When the injured party is a minor, the statute of limitations does not begin running until they turn 18. This gives them until their 21st birthday to file a claim, though a parent or guardian may file on their behalf earlier. What happens if I file a medical malpractice claim too late in DC? If you file after the statute of limitations has expired, the court will almost certainly dismiss your case. You will lose the right to recover any compensation, regardless of how serious your injuries are or how clear the negligence was. Missing the deadline can also end important legal rights before the case is ever heard. Does DC require a Certificate of Merit to file a malpractice lawsuit? Yes. Washington, DC requires plaintiffs to file a Certificate of Merit signed by a qualified healthcare professional at the time the lawsuit is filed. This certificate confirms that the provider deviated from the applicable standard of care. What if the negligent provider works for a government hospital in DC? If the provider is a federal employee, your claim falls under the Federal Tort Claims Act. You must file an administrative claim within two years of the injury before you can sue in federal court. Different procedures and deadlines apply. How much does it cost to hire a medical malpractice attorney at LawMD Chartered? LawMD Chartered works on a contingency fee basis, which means you pay no attorney fees unless we recover compensation for you. Your initial case evaluation is a free consultation. What types of damages can I recover in a DC medical malpractice case? You may be entitled to compensation through medical malpractice civil claims for medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, loss of consortium, and — in fatal cases — wrongful death damages. Washington, DC does not cap economic or non-economic damages in malpractice cases. How long does a medical malpractice case take to resolve in DC? The timeline varies significantly depending on the complexity of the case, the legal process involved, the willingness of the defendant to negotiate, and court scheduling. Cases can resolve in as little as one to two years through settlement, or take longer if they proceed to trial. Why should I choose LawMD Chartered for my DC medical malpractice case? LawMD Chartered offers a unique combination of in-house medical and legal analysis. Our board-certified MDs and attorneys work together from the start of your case, enabling faster evaluations, stronger case preparation, and more credible presentations in court. We serve clients throughout Washington, DC and the surrounding region, and we do not charge fees unless we win. Clients also benefit from clear legal guidance throughout the case. Take the First Step — Speak With a Washington, DC Medical Malpractice Attorney Today Time is not on your side when it comes to medical malpractice claims, and prompt action matters. Every day that passes is a day closer to a filing deadline that could end your case before it begins. If you believe you or a loved one was harmed by a healthcare provider's negligence in Washington, DC, LawMD Chartered is ready to help you understand your legal rights, obtain legal assistance, and take action. Call us today at 833-695-2963 or complete our online form at lawmd.com/contact to schedule your free case evaluation. Our team of board-certified MDs and attorneys will review your case, answer your questions, and help you seek justice through the claims process — at no cost and with no obligation.